Starbucks and Google Announce Underwater Options Exchanges

Posted on Thursday, January 22, 2009 by Frank Roche

In a sign of what’s going to happen in 2009, Starbucks and Google both announced an options exchange for their underwater options.

Starbucks Schedule TO SEC filing included this summary by Howard Schultz, Chairman and CEO, about their underwater options:

Dear Partners,

I am pleased to announce that a proposal to amend our equity incentive plans to permit a voluntary stock option exchange program (“Option Exchange Program”) for our partners will be submitted to shareholders for their approval at Starbucks 2009 Annual Meeting on March 18, 2009.

At Starbucks, we believe that an effective and competitive partner incentive program is critical for the success of our business. Broad-based stock options constitute a key component of our incentive and retention programs because we believe that equity compensation encourages partners to act like owners of the business, motivating them to work toward our success and rewarding their contributions by allowing them to benefit from increases in the value of our shares.

Like many retailers, Starbucks has been, and continues to be, adversely impacted by the global economic crisis. Due to the significant decline of our stock price during the last few years, many of our partners now hold stock options with exercise prices significantly higher than the current market price of our common stock (known as “underwater” stock options).

If we receive shareholder approval, the Option Exchange Program would give eligible partners a one-time opportunity to exchange certain outstanding underwater stock options for a lesser amount of new options that will be granted with lower exercise prices. The number of new stock options would be determined using exchange ratios designed to result in the new stock options having a fair value approximately equal to the stock options that are exchanged. The Option Exchange Program would be approximately expense-neutral from an accounting perspective.

Lazlo Bock, VP of People Operations at Google, wrote about underwater options today on Google’s company blog:

Today we announced our plans to do something more for the people who are responsible for Google’s success — our employees. Recognizing that about 85% of our employees have at least some stock options that are underwater (i.e., have an exercise price higher than the current market price of our common stock), we plan to offer our employees the opportunity to exchange those options. Our goal is to continue to reward our employees for their contributions and do everything we can to keep them engaged and focused on serving our users.

This is big news today folks. Underwater options exchanges might look scary, but they’re going to be done in droves this year. Companies are evaluating their competitive position, and options have retentive value when they are in the money and not hopelessly underwater. Companies who are doing options exchanges early are going to be in a more competitive position early.

Support this post around the web. We would really appreciate it.

digg
delicious
twitter
stumbleupon
email

User Comments

  1. mszypko

    Jan 23rd, 2009

    What type of option exchange program is out there for the shareholders?

    I agree that, as you hypothesize in your other posting, communication may be the new compensation, but I wonder what these messages communicate? How about …”Here is an incentive tied to company performance (in this case stock price) and if we do well we will all reap the benefits along with our shareholders and if we do poorly only the shareholders will be punished!” That is essentially what these programs communicate.

    What ever happened to management? Why cant we expect management to manage in tough times? The time is ripe for them to be providing the “compensation of communication”. Sharing the company vision, the strategy as to how we get out of this mess, the call to arms for all employees to pull together to make this company great again …. even in a tough economy.

    Reprice… exchange ….swap …. they all equal:
    A bailout for poor decisions made within a business
    A bailout for stuff that happens in bad times ( maybe we should reprice in good times too? )
    A bailout for managers who don't have to manage in tough times, they now have more candy to toss …
    A bailout for shareholders who might have been looking to use the proceeds from their investment to retire or pay off their mortgage or send their little ones off to college …..wait … oh never mind no bailout for shareholders

    Sorry for my ranting, I just don't understand why we do these things!

  2. kumara

    Jan 26th, 2009

    Repricing stock options is a bad idea. The very idea behind stock options is defeated by repricing. If company wants to ever reprice, this should require 2/3 rd majority share holder approval. Unfortunately in reality, shareholders are powerless in many of these matters.
    The best course of action is to got out of companies that reprice their options.

Leave a Reply

Looking for a place to add a personal image? Visit www.gravatar.com to get your own gravatar, a globally-recognized avatar. After you're all setup, your personal image will be attached every time you comment.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Starbucks and Google have announced underwater options exchanges. Read about them on KnowHR. [...]